Leveraging Hierarchical Condition Category (HCC) Coding to Improve Overall Healthcare

December 27th, 2022 - Kem Tolliver

Let's take a trip back in time. A time when the healthcare industry was bound by 14,000 diagnosis codes via ICD-9-CM to explain illnesses and injuries. During that time, our medical record documentation was limited based on the tools we had to report diagnosis codes. That time is gone. Since October 2015, we’ve had time to adjust to the increase in our ability to explain the complexity and specificity of our patient's illnesses via ICD-10-CM.

Fast-forward from 2015 to the present. Our ability to accurately diagnose and treat conditions has greatly increased as a result of the expansion of ICD-10-CM. Think about it, how in the world would we have been able to handle a Public Health Emergency (PHE) utilizing ICD-9-CM as our diagnosis infrastructure? 
Not only have we quadrupled the number of diagnosis codes at our disposal over the last 7 years to paint a clearer picture of our population’s health status, but we also have financial drivers such as Risk Adjustment Factors (RAF) that are moving us in the direction of Clinical Documentation Improvement (CDI).  

Table 1: ICD-9-CM and ICD-10-CM Comparison  

Diagnosis Code Tools ICD-9-CM ICD-10-CM  Clinical Documentation Improvement;
V Codes; Segmented into its own classification  Included within the main code classification  Placed in a sensible location for increased utilization 
E Codes  Segmented into its own classification  Included within the main code classification  Placed in a sensible location for increased utilization 
Definitions  Vague / unclear in some instances  More clarity and direction  Clearer definitions take the guesswork out of code selection  
Laterality  Modifier usage assisted with describing laterality  Included in ICD-10-CM codes as applicable  Significant descriptor for bi-lateral anatomic sites 
Specificity  Lacked specificity; which required frequent use of unspecified codes  Anatomical site, severity and etiology are inclusive of codes  Minimizes the need to use vague diagnoses to allow better treatment plans 
Expansion  Limitations on code expansion due to the code design  “X” placeholder is a proactive approach to code expansion  Opportunity is there to now document new illnesses with fewer limitations 


When we think of payer reimbursement, our thoughts turn to CPT codes and the associated Relative Value Units (RVUs). On the other side of the coin are our diagnosis codes; which play a huge role in Risk Adjustment Factors (RAF) as a component of reimbursement.

Diagnosis code optimization is a major factor of Hierarchical Condition Category (HCC) coding to improve our reporting of our patient population's illness severity – which in turn justifies reimbursement needs to care for sicker and “riskier” patient populations.  
Payer sources rely on healthcare practitioners medical record documentation to fund populations healthcare. When our practitioners report lower acuity diagnosis codes, we give the false impression that beneficiaries are healthier than they truly are. Doing so, triggers payer sources to miscalculate healthcare spending – which leads to decreased provider reimbursement – which may lead to limitations in healthcare resources. 

Table 2: Risk Adjustment Factor (RAF) Utilization Cycle

Provider Payer
Selects low acuity, unspecified diagnosis codes and/or does not utilize HCC’s Prepares healthcare spending budget
Continues to treat patient population based on high acuity not previously reported  Obtains providers reported HCCs which are used to calculate RAF
Receives decreased reimbursement or is ineligible for shared savings Decreases future healthcare spending/provider payments due to low acuity RAF

We have a ton of diagnoses that can be used to improve the reporting of our patients' conditions, keep our population healthier by quantifying their illness severity through proper medical record documentation and increased specificity in diagnosis selection. The question we need to ask ourselves is, “What’s stopping us and how can we turn this around?”


A great starting point is to review medical record problem lists and compare them to the assessment & plan to ensure issues are being addressed during that encounter. It’s also a good idea to clean up the problem list and remove/replace unspecified codes with more specific codes. If a diagnosis was not addressed during that encounter, it should not be included. 
If you haven’t already gathered, the use of unspecified codes should only be used when a more specific code is not available. Educate your practitioners on the downside of using unspecified codes to change their code selection habits.  Co-morbidities, complications and manifestations are significant components of HCC Coding so don’t leave them out.  
There are Chronic Care Management (CCM) mechanisms that allow for the treatment and tracking of patients with chronic illnesses and HCC’s. We can utilize CCM CPT codes for regular maintenance of our patient population. There is also the opportunity to prevent or manage hospital readmissions through Transitional Care Management (TCM) CPT codes. As an added bonus, these CPT codes also have higher reimbursement than the typical E/M codes. This is our opportunity to engage with patients who are being discharged from the hospital and keep them in care. We have the power to leverage HCC coding to improve the overall healthcare system by optimizing our use of diagnosis codes.


Questions, comments?

If you have questions or comments about this article please contact us.  Comments that provide additional related information may be added here by our Editors.

Latest articles:  (any category)

Code Sequencing Chapter 15 OB Visits
February 13th, 2023 - Chris Woolstenhulme
Sometimes payer guidelines differ from the official guidelines, this can be confusing, let’s look at a sequencing priority for example in Chapter 15: Pregnancy, childbirth, and the Puerperium (o00-o9A). the guidelines tell us how to code based on the provider's documentation, in addition, it is important to know Chapter 15 codes are never to be used on newborn records, only on the maternal record. Find-A-Code will sequence codes according to the ICD-10-CM guidelines first.
Is the End Really Near?
February 7th, 2023 - Chris Woolstenhulme
What happens once the COVID-19 emergency declarations have ended?
Will 2023 Be the Year of Outsourced Medical Billing?
February 3rd, 2023 - Find-A-Code
Many healthcare providers have chosen to keep medical coding and billing in-house. From HIPAA compliance to the complexity of ICD-10 codes, it has just been easier to keep track of things by not outsourcing medical billing or coding. But things are changing. So much so that 2023 could be the year that outsourced services finally take over.
Three Things To Know When Reporting Prolonged Services in 2023
January 31st, 2023 - Aimee Wilcox
The Evaluation and Management (E/M) changes made in 2021 and again in 2023 brought about new CPT codes and guidelines for reporting prolonged services. Just as Medicare disagreed with CPT in the manner in which prolonged service times should be calculated, they did so again with the new 2023 changes. Here are three things you should know when reporting prolonged services for all E/M services.
The Curious Relationship Between CPT Codes and Actual Treatments
January 30th, 2023 - Find-A-Code
Common sense seems to dictate that medical billing codes, like CPT codes for example, are only considered after medical treatment has been provided. After all, the codes are simply a representation of diagnosed conditions and treatment services provided – for billing purposes. But there is a curious relationship between these codes and actual treatments.
Why Medical Billing Codes Are Critical To Healthcare Delivery
January 30th, 2023 - Find-A-Code
Medical coders play a critical role in determining how healthcare delivery is reported for record keeping and billing purposes. Likewise, the codes they know so well are equally critical. They have been around for decades. They were originally developed and implemented to make reporting and billing easier in a healthcare system that was becoming incredibly more complex. The system is even more complex today.
Why Knowing Medical Terminology Makes Coding Easier
January 27th, 2023 - Find-A-Code
You are excited about beginning your training as a professional medical coder. You're expecting to pass the exam and earn your certification. The future is looking bright until, as you are perusing the educational material, you suddenly realize you're going to have to learn medical terminology.

Home About Terms Privacy

innoviHealth® - 62 E 300 North, Spanish Fork, UT 84660 - Phone 801-770-4203 (9-5 Mountain)

Copyright © 2000-2023 innoviHealth Systems®, Inc. - CPT® copyright American Medical Association